Advertisement
American Journal of Kidney Diseases

Ethical issues in living organ donation: Donor autonomy and beyond

      Abstract

      Despite nearly 50 years of experience with living kidney donation, ethical questions about this practice continue to haunt us today. In this editorial I will address two of them: (1) Given the possibility of limited understanding and coercion, how can we be sure that a person who offers to donate an organ is acting autonomously? and (2) Do people have a right to donate? The universal requirement for informed consent is the traditional method for ensuring that a person is acting autonomously. But, while obtaining fully informed consent is desirable, it may not always be achievable or necessary. When the recipient is very dear to the potential donor, the donor may base his decision primarily on care and concern rather than on a careful weighing of risks and benefits. I will argue that consent that emanates from such deep affection should be considered just as valid as consent that is fully informed. But consent is not enough. There is no absolute right to donate an organ. If there were such a right, then some physician would be obligated to remove an offered organ upon request, regardless of the risks involved. I do not believe that physicians have such an obligation. Physicians are moral agents who are responsible for their actions and for the welfare of their patients. Therefore, while the values and goals of the potential donor should be given great weight during the decision-making process, physicians may justifiably refuse to participate in living organ donation when they believe that the risks for the donor outweigh the benefits. © 2001 by the National Kidney Foundation, Inc.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to American Journal of Kidney Diseases
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Merrill JP
        • Murray JE
        • Harrison JH
        • Guild WR
        Successful homotransplantation of the human kidney between identical twins.
        JAMA. 1956; 160: 277-282
        • Tilney NL
        Renal transplantation between identical twins: Areview.
        World J Surg. 1986; 10: 381-388
        • Moore FD
        New problems for surgery.
        Science. 1964; 144: 388-392
        • Steiner RW
        • Gert B
        Ethical selection of living kidney donors.
        Am J Kidney Dis. 2000; 36: 677-686
        • Caplan A
        Must I be my brother's keeper? Ethical issues in the use of living donors as sources of liver and other solid organs.
        Transplant Proc. 1993; 25: 1997-2000
        • Beauchamp TL
        • Childress JF
        Respect for Autonomy.
        in: Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Oxford University Press, New York1994: pp120-pp188
        • Majeske RA
        • Parker LS
        • Frader JE
        In search of an ethical framework for consideration of decisions regarding live donation.
        in: Organ and Tissue Donation: Ethical, Legal, and Policy Issues. Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale, IL1996: 89-101
        • Spital A
        Ethical issues in living related donors.
        in: The Ethics of Organ Transplantation. Elsvier Science, New York, NY2001: 89-123
        • Simmons RG
        • Marine SK
        • Simmons RL
        Gift of Life. The Effect of Organ Transplantation on Individual, Family, and Societal Dynamics.
        in: Transaction Books, New Brunswick, NJ1987: 153-165 (171, 241)
        • Smith MD
        • Kappell DF
        • Province MA
        • Hong BA
        • Robson AM
        • Dutton S
        • Guzman T
        • Hoff J
        • Shelton L
        • Cameron E
        • Emerson W
        • Glass NR
        • Hopkins J
        • Peterson C
        Living-related kidney donors: A multicenter study of donor education, socioeconomic adjustment, and rehabilitation.
        Am J Kidney Dis. 1986; 8: 223-233
        • Caplan A
        Am I my borther's keeper?.
        Suffolk Univ Law Rev. 1995; 27: 900-914
        • Fellner CH
        • Marshall JR
        Twelve kidney donors.
        JAMA. 1968; 206: 2703-2707
        • Fellner CH
        • Marshall JR
        Kidney donors—The myth of informed consent.
        Am J Psychiatry. 1970; 126: 1245-1251
        • The Authors for the Live Organ Donor Consensus Group
        Consensus statement on the live organ donor.
        JAMA. 2000; 284: 2919-2926
        • Nuffield Council on Bioethics
        Human Tissue Ethical and Legal Issues.
        Nuffield Council on Bioethics, London1995
        • Hardwig J
        In search of an ethics of personal relationships.
        in: Person to Person. Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA1989: 63-81
        • Pierce EG
        • Pierce RA
        “The agony and the ectasy.”.
        Transplant Proc. 1973; 5: 1067-1068
        • Spital A
        • Spital M
        Living kidney donation: Attitudes outside the transplant center.
        Arch Intern Med. 1988; 148: 1077-1080
        • Faden RR
        • Beauchamp TL
        A History and Theory of Informed Consent.
        in: Oxford University Press, New York1986: 344-345
        • Crouch RA
        • Elliott C
        Moral agency and the family: The case of living related organ transplantation.
        Cambridge Quarterly Healthcare Ethics. 1999; 8: 275-287
        • Kasiske B
        • Ravenscraft M
        • Ramos EL
        • Gaston RS
        • Bia MJ
        • Danovitch GM
        The evaluation of living renal transplant donors: clinical practice guidelines.
        J Am Soc Nephrol. 1996; 7: 2288-2313
        • Ubel PA
        • Mahowald MB
        Ethical and legal issues regarding living donors.
        in: Encyclopedia of Bioethics. Simon Schuster Macmillan, New York1995: 1865-1871
        • Fehrman-Ekholm I
        • Brink B
        • Ericsson C
        • Elinder CG
        • Dunér F
        • Lundgren G
        Kidney donors don't regret.
        Transplantation. 2000; 69: 2067-2071
        • Matas AJ
        • Garvey CA
        • Jacobs CL
        • Kahn JP
        Nondirected donation of kidneys from living donors.
        N Engl J Med. 2000; 343: 433-436
        • Spital A
        When a stranger offers a kidney: Ethical issues in living organ donation.
        Am J Kidney Dis. 1998; 32: 676-691
        • Elliott C
        Doing harm: Living organ donors, clinical research and The Tenth Man.
        J Med Ethics. 1995; 21: 91-96
        • Harris J
        Wonderwoman and Superman. The Ethics of Human Biotechnology.
        in: Oxford University Press, Oxford1992: 113
        • Spital A
        Living kidney donation: When is it justified?.
        AKF Nephrol Lett. 1988; 5: 1-15
        • Childress JF
        Who Should Decide? Paternalism in Health Care.
        in: Oxford University Press, New York1982: 21-79
        • Singer PA
        • Siegler M
        Whose kidney is it anyway? Ethical considerations in living kidney donation.
        AKF Nephrol Lett. 1988; 5: 16-20
        • Spital A
        The ethics of unconventional living organ donation.
        Clin Transplant. 1991; 5: 322-326
        • World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki
        Ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects.
        JAMA. 2000; 284: 3043-3045
        • Spital A
        • Spital M
        Donor's choice or Hobson's Choice.
        Arch Intern Med. 1985; 145: 1297-1301
        • Olbrisch ME
        • Benedict SM
        • Haller DL
        • Levenson JL
        Psychosocial assessment of living organ donors: Clinical and ethical considerations.
        Prog Transplant. 2001; 11: 40-49